Monday 14 March 2011

Selling Antique Swords on the Internet and my Personal Reputation

Selling Antique Swords on the Internet and my Personal Reputation

For a number of years I have been selling antique swords to customers throughout the world and have earned a reputation for fairness and reliability.  I am always happy to correspond with customers and talk about this fascinating area of history and collecting.  I am also a great believer in freedom of speech on the internet but please be aware that this freedom should not extend to individuals committing libel and spreading outrageous falsehoods about a person's character and reputation.  Unfortunately, I have been a persistent victim of this anonymous and cowardly practice (as have other sword collectors, dealers and auction houses that have innocently crossed this individual's path) and I ask anyone reading blogs that spread this malicious material to simply make up your own mind as regards the kind of sad mentality that would spend hours writing anonymously about individuals they have never met and who have no right to reply.  Interestingly, the originator of these blogs is also a seller of antique swords and therefore a direct competitor.  I leave the reader to summise what they want from that fact.

Best regards,

Harvey Withers

Monday 8 November 2010

INTERNET TROLLS AND THE SWORD COLLECTING COMMUNITY

Be aware that trolls really do exist and they are in resident in our sword collecting community!  There are individuals out there who gain enormous pleasure from writing completely false and libellous comments in blogs and forums about those who both collect and sell antique swords.  They are called internet trolls and usually suffer from various forms of mental illness and deep self-loathing.  Feel sorry for them and their multiple personality problems but don't believe what they write!  If you read anything in a blog that attacks an individual, look at the kind of language used - invariably it takes on a ranting tone and includes lots of personal attacks and lies - interestingly, it usually concerns the personal appearance of the victim which probably indicates an physical inferiority complex by the internet troll himself (or herself of course!).  Normally their blog not only attacks an individual, but a whole group of people, organisations or companies, who they have decided (in their own twisted view of the world) should be relentlessly attacked from the comfort (and safety) of their computer many hundreds, if not thousands of miles away.  How cowardly is that?  If you read garbage from any individual on the internet purporting to be an expert on antique swords and using multiple blogs and bogus forums (peopled by himself using aliases) to attack both me and other persons, I suggest you take whatever is said with a very large pinch of salt and just carefully read the rantings and make your own mind up!

I have been told that the troll below is pretty representative of what these subterranean folk look like.  Do you know anyone who looks like this...?

Saturday 6 November 2010

IMITATION IS SUPPOSED TO THE SINCEREST FORM OF FLATTERY - OR IS IT IN CHINA?

It appears that a Chinese-American gentleman(sic) by the name of Zhao Aiguo (resident in Philadelphia) has completely copied  my book, World Swords 1600-1945 An Illustrated Price Guide for Collectors and published it under his own name!


Please be aware Mr Aiguo that your complete disregard for my ownership of the copyright for this book will be spread far and wide on the internet.  For any of you who are interested in seeing who this person is, see below at these book shots that he is using to advertise the book for sale. Amazing!








The web site where these page shots were placed is http://bbs.sssc.cn/viewthread.php?tid=1061789&extra=page%3D2&page=10

I checked back today and they appear to have disappeared - maybe Mr Zhao Aiguo has got the message but he has still stolen my book in its entirety and I will be checking the internet very carefully for any of his illegal activities.

Friday 1 October 2010

INTERESTED IN FINDNG OUT MORE ABOUT ANTIQUE SWORDS?

If you are interested in finding out more about your antique swords or would just like a chat with fellow enthusiasts, then I can highly recommend this web site - http://www.swordforum.com/.  It's a great forum for discussions on all types and periods of swords, from swords of antiquity to the 20th Century.  Forumites are friendly and knowledgeable - the perfect combination!

Best regards,

Harvey Withers

CARE AND PRESERVATION OF ANTIQUE SWORDS BY HARVEY WITHERS

Here is the text from a book of mine - British Military Swords 1786-1912 An Illustrated Price Guide for Collectors.  It tells you about how to preserve and look after your antique swords.  Hope that you find the information helpful!

 The correct care and preservation of a sword is not an easy task.  Many a fine sword has been ruined by overzealous cleaning and poor attempts at amateur “restoration”.  If you are new to this field of collecting, the basic rule is:

IF YOU ARE NOT SURE ABOUT HOW TO PRESERVE YOUR SWORD, OR FEEL THAT YOU DO NOT HAVE THE NECESSARY SKILLS TO COMPLETE THE
PROCESS, ASK SOMEONE WHO DOES.

This “someone” might be a fellow collector with experience of restoration, a dealer who might be able to tell you him/herself, or “knows a man who knows a man“.  As time goes by, you will meet people who can offer sound advice.  They will be speaking from years of experience, including mistakes that they themselves made at the start!

If the restoration job is complex, it is always better to hand over your sword to an expert restorer and let them do the tricky work.  Expert restorers can be found through word of mouth via dealers and collectors, and some advertise through related militaria journals and magazines.  There is also a lively circle of dealers and collectors who speak to eachother through internet web sites devoted to collecting edged weapons (see page 176), and they are always more than happy to exchange tips and contacts.

You might think that after paying a considerable sum for your sword, the very last thing that you are wish to do is spend even more cash.  This attitude is wrong, and if you intend to keep and preserve a fine collection of British military swords, a little extra spent on preservation will be a sound investment.

Saying this, I do not mean to frighten away the collector by saying that they cannot or should not do any kind of preservation work.  Far from it.  An expert should normally be called in when there are complex or detailed areas of preservation or restoration work to be addressed, particularly when this might require the sword to be taken apart or broken parts to be repaired.  I have visited too many auction rooms and fairs to see the results of amateur botched repairs to hilts, blades and scabbards.  Here are some basic emergency procedures that are relatively simple to undertake but vital if wishing to hold back the ravages of time, and ensure that the sword does not deteriorate any further.

 BLADES AND METAL
SCABBARDS/FITTINGS

One of the first problems that you may encounter concerns the accumulation of corrosion e.g. rust.  The use of a Break Free oil which dislodges the rust is recommended, but not on blades with blue and gilt finish, as it has been known to loosen the gilding.  Alcohol or kerosene is light enough to clean these delicate blades, and when completely wiped clean of this, a covering of fine carabellum wax is applied.  This provides a protective seal which keeps out moisture.

There are a number of specialist waxes on the market. I recommend Museum Wax or Renaissance/Becketts Wax.  All these products are available from specialist hardware or gun supply shops, and a quick trawl through the internet will also locate a number of merchants who can supply mail order.

Vaseline petroleum jelly or pure mineral oil/gel will also protect the blade from future moisture, but it is important to stress that you will need to inspect the sword on a regular basis to see if any rust or corrosion has returned.  Some swords have very heavy areas of rust where the use of  Break Free might not be very effective and other options need to be considered.

 

In these cases, a very fine abrasive might be used, but you must decide whether the blade etching or hilt/scabbard plating might be damaged or worn by this method.  It all comes down to how you want the sword to look, and there are some collectors who cannot resist removing the age or patina of a sword because they believe that a highly polished sword is more attractive.  Thankfully, there are not a great number of these individuals, but you will continue to see swords that have been polished to a gleaming state and there is little you can do to return its character.  Do not let this be a reason not to buy a particular sword.  I would rather acquire a highly polished but rare piece, than none at all!

Another important point to remember is that constant handling of the sword will endanger its condition, especially when moisture from hands comes into contact with the blade.  Any collector of Japanese swords will testify to the permanent damage to the blade that can result from fingermarks that have not been immediately removed.  The wearing of lint free cotton gloves might sound a bit drastic but it ensures that the sword is kept dry.  Remember to invest in a couple of pairs.  This ensures that there is a spare pair on hand when that inquisitive friend pays a visit.

HILTS, SCABBARDS AND
LEATHER / FISHSKIN GRIPS

A toothbrush and some ammonia detergent or soapy water is effective in rooting out dirt and grime from recesses in hilts and scabbard mounts.  The main priority is to save any original gilding, so do not use any abrasives in this area.

Use a good leather care product on grips and scabbards to avoid drying out.  It should also have a high wax content as it will act as a long term anti-drying sealant.  Regular inspection of leather fittings should be done in conjunction with the inspection of the metal parts.  Try not to display swords with leather scabbards or grips too near areas of heat, particularly central heating radiators.  It is probably stating the obvious but direct sunlight will never be advantageous to an antique piece.  For fishskin grips I recommend a little baby oil or olive oil to allow the material to breathe again.  Do not rub too hard on grips as they can be very flaky and pieces can easily come away.

Tuesday 21 September 2010

Harvey Withers - Antique Sword Dealer and Author

Hello.

Here you can find information on Harvey J S Withers, antique sword dealer and author.

I have been collecting and dealing in antique military swords and edged weapons for the well over 15 years and over that time have handled many varied and interesting pieces.  These have ranged from Ancient Celtic Long Swords to English gentleman's smallswords of the Eighteenth Century.  I love sourcing interesting and historical pieces and am expecially excited when I can determine the original owner.  This literally brings a sword to life and gives us a fascinating insight into a sometimes forgotten individual and his place in history.

Handling and photographing so many swords over the years has enabled me to accumulate a vast library of sword images and I have used them to produce a number of sword related reference books.  Here they are below:

British Military Swords 1786-1912: The Regulation Patterns (Studio Jupiter Military Publishing),

World Swords 1400-1945 (Studio Jupiter Military Publishing), The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Swords and Sabres(Lorenz Books)

The Scottish Sword 1600-1945 (Paladin Press). 

See the reviews for my books below.

I am always happy to make contact and chat with fellow collectors and it goes without saying that I am always on the look out for new swords for my inventory.  You can view my current swords for sale at http://www.britishmilitaryswords.co.uk/ and E-Bay auctions at http://www.antiqueswordsonline.com/.

Best wishes and happy hunting!,

Harvey J S Withers

If you are interested in adding to your knowledge of antique military swords or maybe just seeing what they are worth, please take a look at my authored books below.  They are produced specially for the sword collector and are full colour with hundreds of original photographs and illustrations.

Book reviews for publications by Harvey J S Withers:

British Military Swords 1786-1912 An Illustrated Price for Collectors

ISBN-0-9545910-03
"It is by far and away the best reference guide to Victorian era British swords and is highly recommended"
Stuart Mowbray, Man at Arms magazine.
"Well researched, well written and well illustrated, this book is an essential addition for the sword collector"
Gun Mart magazine.
"Contains plenty of information......a valuable addition to our library"
National Army Museum, London.
"....is a very worthwhile addition to any sword collectors bookshelf"
The Armourer magazine.
If you collect British military swords you will want this book. Containing over 1500 unpublished full colour photographs it is the first full colour price guide for collectors of British regulation military swords. The book contains detailed photographs of all the regulation patterns from 1786 - 1912 including:

  • Infantry Swords 

  • Cavalry Swords

  •  Scottish Swords

  • General Officers' Swords

  • Naval Swords

  • Departmental Swords

  • British Sword Maker/Retailer Index

  • Close up Shots of Blade and Hilt

  • Sword Markings

  • Wilkinson Sword Serial Number Index

  • Sword Knots
Buy this book directly from http://www.britishmilitaryswords.co.uk/ or via E-Bay under user id - anglianswords.

World Swords 1600-1945  An Illustrated Price for Collectors   

ISBN-0-9545910-1-1 
"This beautifully produced volume...wide-ranging and eclectic work cataloguing a large selection of swords dating from medieval times to the demise of the sword as a combat weapon...gives the generalist the knowledge and confidence to identify and know the value of any commonly encountered sword..."
Classic Arms and Militaria Magazine.
"Almost 300 pages of colourful photographs and informative text...is an entry level guide which also serves as a source of reference to the more experienced collector..."
The Armourer Magazine.
"I am delighted to write the Foreword...because it gives a broad introduction to the types of swords that one might might find in the marketplace..."
Professor Richard Holmes.
  • Over 2000 full colour photographs
  • Current market values in $US and £Sterling
  • Includes pre-1750 swords Swords
  • Infantry Swords
  • Cavalry Swords
  • Scottish Swords
  • Naval Swords
  • Japanese swords
  • Smallswords
  • Historical background
  • Foreword by Professor Richard Holmes
    (Author of "Redcoat", TV presenter of "War Walks")
  • 300 pages laminated hardback
  • First edition author signed copies available
This book can be purchased directly from http://www.britishmilitaryswords.co.uk/ or via E-Bay under user id - anglianswords. 

The Scottish Sword 1600 - 1945 An Illustrated History 



ISBN-13: 978-1581607130
 "Superbly illustrated in colour...a must for the library of any serious edged weapon collector" 
 The Armourer Magazine
With more than 1,200 gorgeous, full-color photographs and authentic period illustrations,The Scottish Sword pays tribute to the swords most associated with the Highland soldier, including:

  • Two-handed swords

  • English basket hilts

  • Jacobite basket hilts

  • Regulation basket hilts

  • Non-regulation swords
There is also a chapter on Scottish sword makers and retailers who supplied swords to the Scottish Highlander and a comprehensive bibliography pointing the collector and student towards the most informative books on the subject.
This book can be purchased directly from http://www.amazon.com/ or http://www.paladin-press.com/